Recently, I lost one of my most consistent voiceover clients. It wasn’t because I turned in subpar work. It wasn’t because I missed a deadline or failed to communicate. It was because of something far simpler—and far more common these days:
They decided to use an AI voice instead.
This particular client runs a successful “faceless” YouTube channel. I’d been narrating their videos for a long time—long enough that the audience got used to my voice and storytelling rhythm. But eventually, like so many others facing tight margins, the creator made a financial decision: switch to an AI tool that could generate narration instantly, without needing to pay a human.
On paper, I get it. AI is fast. It’s cheap. It never needs a water break or a retake.
But then the videos went live.
And something surprising happened:
The comments lit up with people saying they missed the old narrator. Some even said they stopped watching the video halfway through because the new voice just didn’t connect. Others said it felt robotic, lifeless, or off-putting—despite the fact that the script and visuals hadn’t changed.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7bHxbe4b8g&t=833s
To be clear, I don’t share this out of bitterness. I genuinely like the creator and understand their situation. But it was a reminder--a validating one—that human connection matters.
A well-trained voice actor does more than just read a script. We interpret. We shape tone, emotion, and pacing. We tell the story behind the words. And most importantly, we make the audience feel something.
AI can generate a voice.
But it can’t generate presence.
It can’t create trust.
It can’t be remembered.
So if you’re a content creator, brand manager, or business owner thinking about the trade-off between cost and quality—remember this post. And remember those comments.
Sometimes, trying to save a few bucks on narration can end up costing you something far more valuable: your audience.
🎙️ Need a narrator your audience will actually listen to?
Click here to work with me »
--
Mark Bowen
Professional Voice Actor | markjohnbowen.com
They decided to use an AI voice instead.
This particular client runs a successful “faceless” YouTube channel. I’d been narrating their videos for a long time—long enough that the audience got used to my voice and storytelling rhythm. But eventually, like so many others facing tight margins, the creator made a financial decision: switch to an AI tool that could generate narration instantly, without needing to pay a human.
On paper, I get it. AI is fast. It’s cheap. It never needs a water break or a retake.
But then the videos went live.
And something surprising happened:
The comments lit up with people saying they missed the old narrator. Some even said they stopped watching the video halfway through because the new voice just didn’t connect. Others said it felt robotic, lifeless, or off-putting—despite the fact that the script and visuals hadn’t changed.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B7bHxbe4b8g&t=833s
To be clear, I don’t share this out of bitterness. I genuinely like the creator and understand their situation. But it was a reminder--a validating one—that human connection matters.
A well-trained voice actor does more than just read a script. We interpret. We shape tone, emotion, and pacing. We tell the story behind the words. And most importantly, we make the audience feel something.
AI can generate a voice.
But it can’t generate presence.
It can’t create trust.
It can’t be remembered.
So if you’re a content creator, brand manager, or business owner thinking about the trade-off between cost and quality—remember this post. And remember those comments.
Sometimes, trying to save a few bucks on narration can end up costing you something far more valuable: your audience.
🎙️ Need a narrator your audience will actually listen to?
Click here to work with me »
--
Mark Bowen
Professional Voice Actor | markjohnbowen.com
RSS Feed